Sunday, November 12, 2006
"Interchange" a Misunderstood Term (WayTooHigh.com)
A primary mission of WayTooHigh.com - The Credit Card Interchange Report is to draw attention to what has become a $30 billion dollar annual tax on retailers and consumers.
Interchange fees are anything but an innocuous expense. It adds up and is misunderstood. Rather than calling these hidden taxes an "interchange" fee, a better description is a simply a tax or surcharge that is mandated by the credit card associations and banking cartel.
Click here for more background
[Commentary: WayTooHigh.com]
Saturday, November 11, 2006
In Tribute - Five Years Ago Today
Friday, November 10, 2006
Thursday, November 09, 2006
We Pause to Remember Ed Bradley
"Visa, MasterCard in N.Z. Regulator Price-Fixing Suit" (Bloomberg)
[Source: Bloomberg]
"Commission Alleges Credit Card Price-fixing" (Stuff.co.nz)
The commission said it filed a statement of claim in the High Court in Wellington yesterday, alleging that fixing the interchange fees was anti-competitive."
[source: Stuff.co.nz]
Saturday, November 04, 2006
Friday, November 03, 2006
Every Credit and Debit Card Receipt Should Include Interchange Charge (WayTooHigh.com)
There should be complete disclosure of each total merchant interchange fee as a separate line item on every consumer charge receipt. This crystal-clear posting of the exact interchange charge (in dollars and as a percent of the total sale) is being recommended by WayTooHigh.com - The Credit Card Interchange Report.
While merchants insist the nearly one-hundred separate, bank-imposed, interchange fees are a hidden tax on consumers, Visa and MasterCard explain otherwise. This simple and immediate resolution to this argument that it is a hidden tax is to show consumers exactly what they paid to the banks from each purchase when they use their credit and debit cards.
Until the interchange litigation is resolved, WayTooHigh.com - The Credit Card Interchange Report is recommending that the credit card companies voluntarily disclosure and make transparent the actual, total interchange fee and percent of the total transaction charged for each purchase. This dollar amount and percent figure should be clearly imprinted on all electronic credit card receipts.
This single line item on every electronic credit and debit card receipt should be identified as the "bank processing fee" to create a more transparent understanding of interchange fees. Unlike all other costs-of-goods-sold, this single charge is the one that results from horizontal price-fixing where merchants have little or no ability to negotiate. These postings on every receipt will enable merchants to understand exactly how much is paid to process each transaction. And, candidly it will also enrage consumers too, who are unfamiliar with this charge. Posting the interchange fee on every receipt will swiftly prove the growing argument that these illegal, price-fixing fees and its annual $25 billion burden is a "hidden tax on consumers." Just as sales tax is identified as a separate line item, this too will spark greater consumer awareness and better disclosure these interchange fees.
How about it Visa® and MasterCard®?
[source: WayTooHigh.com]
Monday, October 30, 2006
MasterCard® Interchange Rate Schedules on Website (via PRNewswire)
We wonder whether last week's WayTooHigh.com press release helped speed up MasterCard's® decision to just one-week later begin posting the long awaited fees online?
MasterCard has issued a press release today announcing that their anticipated posting of U.S. merchants interchange fee schedules are now posted on its website. Click here to download the MasterCard interchange rates and criteria; it is 72 pages long.
Think how much time and effort would be saved if the exact fee was instead listed on every charge receipt?
If we are confused, and we are the lead plaintiff in the merchant antitrust litigation, imagine the local shop owner who downloads the rate schedules?
Take a look for yourself - try to identify what the exact interchange rates are. Can you? How do these U.S. merchant rates differ from other nations? What accounts for the difference and why are rates averaging 1.7% in the U.S. all the way to zero in other nations? [There are no interchange fees in Canada for PIN debit cards].
The merchant classifications are broken down by category, from cruise lines, airlines, car rental charges to restaurants and even as detailed as the fees for MasterCard PIN debit POS for convenience stores.
According to the MasterCard press release, Walt Macnee, president, Americas, MasterCard, said "... [The] merchant community has asked us for greater transparency, and we are pleased to accommodate their request... Just publishing rates alone could lead to confusion among merchants who may be seeing this information for the first time... We are confident that we are providing merchants with the information they need to understand the interchange rates and structure and determine which rates may apply to their transactions. We want to have an ongoing dialogue with merchants, acquirers and other interested parties about the format and content of our rate disclosure, as we plan to update this document regularly."
Also mentioned within their press release was a quote from Joshua Peirez, Group Executive, Global Public Policy for MasterCard, who said "MasterCard has been a leader in providing greater transparency in the payments industry..."
If MasterCard really wants to comply with the above comments, there is no more transparent, simply way to disclose interchange fees than to actually post the exact charge on every cardholders debit and credit card receipt. Click here for background.
[Source: via MasterCard press release and WayTooHigh.com commentary]
Saturday, October 28, 2006
Mitch Goldstone to Address Intl Consumer Electronics Show (WayTooHigh.com)
[Source: via CES, and WayTooHigh.com]
Friday, October 27, 2006
FedEx® vs. Visa® and MasterCard® (WayTooHigh.com)
The two leading credit card associations had similar costs to process payments. It was manual. Today, it is electronic, instant and highly efficient. Back then, merchants like us ordered bundles of carbon copy credit card receipts. We mailed it to a clearing house and it took days to process each payment. Fraud and other costs must have been mountainous. But, back then, the merchant interchange fees were cost-based.
Moving forward to the present.
We primarily use FedEx for all rush deliveries for our online boutique photo service. With the push of a few key strokes, the labels are designed and printed on standard paper. Everything is super fast, efficient and cost effective. Costs are streamlined, even with the recent ascending fuel prices. But, we can choose other freight carriers too.
Today, it seems that the banking and card payment industry are among the few which continually raise rates. Like OPEC, the banking cartel is in charge of setting fees. Even though other industries are embracing technology to lower costs, the card associations are raising theirs. In many cases, merchant interchange fees are the third most significant cost after rent and payroll. We even read that without intervention, the fees may even grow to exceed the cost of rent in coming years!
Through gimmicks and reward contests, retailers are being forced to pay more. These billions of dollars in hidden taxes levied on merchants and consumers are no small change. The fees are controlled by the banking cartel which stands accused of conspiring to set merchant fees at artificially high levels and illegally fix prices by agreement.
(Source: WayTooHigh.com)
"MasterCard® to Defend Role in EU As Middleman in Processing Fees" (WSJ)
Carl Munson, an associate MasterCard general council was quoted in the article as saying: "We continue to assert that interchange fees are necessary in a four-party system." While Mr. Munson explained that the value to the system is to elevate the level of competition and efficiencies. To us, it seems that the greater benefactor of the fees are the banks at the expense of retailers and consumers.
[Source: via WSJ]
Thursday, October 26, 2006
"30 Minute Photos Etc. Not Backing Down" (Irvine World News)
By YOLANDA SANCHEZ IRVINE WORLD NEWS, [Oct 26, p 19]
Last year, 30 Minute Photos Etc. received notice that interchange fees, the fee that banks charge retailers when customers pay with credit cards, would increase for frequent-flier cards.
Mitch Goldstone, co-owner of 30 Minute Photos Etc. and 30minphotos.com, wouldn’t hear of it.
Goldstone became lead plaintiff in a lawsuit filed in June 2005 against Visa, MasterCard and a host of banks that issue the credit cards. The lawsuit accuses banks of violating antitrust laws by conspiring to fix the fees at levels that aren’t justified by the costs of processing transactions.
Credit card companies counter that the rates are determined by the open marketplace and the services they provide increase sales.
Here’s an interview with Goldstone.
Why did you decide to take this on and be named as the lead plaintiff?
It upset me because it meant customers were being taken for a ride. After we received the letter I contacted Visa and MasterCard but received no response. I was then quoted in the Wall Street Journal. (Goldstone was then contacted by the law firm that filed the suit). I never thought I would be the lead plaintiff representing all of these merchants, but it is something that is very important to me.
Why do you think this is such an important issue?
Because it impacts every retailer and consumer. The banks are doing what the railroad industry did 100 years ago when it said to farmers this is what we are going to charge you to transport goods. Farmers had no choice because otherwise their goods would spoil. Visa and MasterCard account for 80 percent of all credit card transactions.
How have you seen these fees change?
In 1990 we had to take a credit card and imprint it on a stack of carbon copies. We mailed our copies to a facility in Florida where they were checked for fraud and other things. That is what the fees were created for. Back then there were about 10 interchange fees. Now there are about 100. But if you pay with a check the interchange fee is zero even though there are a lot of clearing costs.
When and why did you launch WayTooHigh.com?
We launched it in spring 2005. I was receiving so many calls and inquiries from the media and merchants all over the U.S. and I couldn’t talk with everyone. Now I just say go to Way Too High.
What stage is the lawsuit in and what’s the next step?
It is being heard in federal court in New York. It has been merged together with the other lawsuits – there are upwards of 50 separate lawsuits – in a multi-district litigation, with my law firm being lead firm. The next step is to get class action status. This will get all retailers in on the case.
What resolution would you like to see come out of this?
Ultimately there should be no interchange fees; there’s no need for it, and that is why this case is so important. I’d like to have Visa and MasterCard print out on every receipt the exact amount that goes to interchange fees.
[Source: Irvine World News]
Wednesday, October 25, 2006
Detailed Fee Postings Already Exist (WayTooHigh.com)
Even though tax is added to the charge, that too is broken down on receipts. With technology today, posting the exact merchant interchange fee on every credit and debit card receipt would improve transparency and explain why consumers and retailers are battling the credit card associations and their member banks.
Providing retailers with the choice of adding these unambiguous and transparent interchange fees as an item on each receipt should be made available by 'Black Friday' - the busy shopping day after Thanksgiving. If the credit card associations can flip a switch to raise fees, they should also look into flipping another switch to print those fees on receipts. As retail business owners since 1990 and owner of a national ecommerce business, we would chose to include those fees on every customers receipt.
[Source: WayTooHigh.com]
Overview: How a Southern California Retailer Became Lead Plaintiff (WayTooHigh.com)
Reported by Robert Barnett, freelance writer in Los Angeles and contributing editor of the University of Southern California's Marshall Magazine.
Monday, October 23, 2006
Printing Exact Merchant Interchange Fee on Charge Receipts by Thanksgiving (WayTooHigh.com)
Irvine, CA October 24, 2006 -- WayTooHigh.com said if Visa® and MasterCard Worldwide® would post the exact merchant interchange fees on every credit card receipt it would accelerate attention to the $30 billion annual hidden tax on consumers and retailers. This relief is being championed by the editors of WayTooHigh.com -- The Credit Card Interchange Report.
Visa USA Inc. has already begun posting a matrix of perplexing rate schedules and scores of fees on its website; MasterCard plans a similar program soon.
"A more straightforward pricing model to easily obtain fee schedules is in place at most other businesses," explained Mitch Goldstone and Carl Berman, WayTooHigh.com co-editors and lead plaintiffs in the antitrust litigation against the two leading credit card associations and its member banks.
As an example, Goldstone said "when consumers order concert tickets from Ticketmaster® the receipt includes the exact 'convenience charge,' 'delivery' and 'order processing fees.' When packages are sent via Federal Express®, a detailed price quote pops up on the online ordering page to provide the exact 'fuel surcharge' and other fees. If Federal Express' rates are too high, consumers can choose another carrier. But, with an 80% market monopoly, retailers are forced to accept the two leading payment card brands."
Some restaurants even post recommended tips on the receipts for average, good and exceptional service.
"While not endorsing a particular solution, it would be more helpful for consumers if there were unambiguous and transparent interchange fees for each transaction -- right on the charge receipt," said Goldstone, president and CEO of the Irvine, Calif-based 30 Minute Photos Etc. and 30minphotos.com, the national online boutique photo service. Goldstone and Berman's company was the first to file a federal complaint against Visa, MasterCard and its member banks back in June 2005 [MDL 1720].
WayTooHigh.com recently profiled several other lead plaintiffs. Some publicly waged concerns about Visa opaquely publishing its U.S. interchange fee schedule in an attempt to appease retailers angered by the fees charged on card transactions.
Goldstone explained that the current Visa and MasterCard fee structures "resemble a distinctively strong onion flavor with multiple layers of confusion. To rid watery eyes when pealing onions, a solution is to soak it in water, but currently there is no fix for those nearly one-hundred separate and ambiguous, unbridled merchants card fees."
"Disclosing the exact interchange fee on every credit card receipt will help consumers and retailers better understand the real extent of these charges," commented Goldstone who explained that "average credit card interchange fee in the U.S. is about 1.7% of the total charge."
Just as sales tax is included on receipts, Goldstone believes that more transparency for the merchant interchange tax would lead to more competition among card networks. By doing so, he said "the volume of consumer and retailer outrage will be amplified, especially if this fee posting was implemented before 'Black Friday' -- the day after Thanksgiving which is among the busiest retail shopping days of the year."
Background: WayTooHigh.com -- The Credit Card Interchange Report has more than 525 news and commentary posting on its website. 30 Minute Photos Etc. was founded in 1990 and operates a retail photo center and nationwide online boutique photo service. The company is lead plaintiff in the payment card interchange fee antitrust litigation. Goldstone is a well-known leader in the photo industry who regularly addresses photo imaging industry conferences across the country. He will be addressing the Las Vegas Consumer Electronics Show in January.
###
[Source: WayTooHigh.com]
Sunday, October 22, 2006
"Credit Card Fees You Didn't Know You Pay" (Letter to the Editor, Washington Post)
It is no surprise to merchants that the recent Government Accountability Office report found that credit card issuers are imposing excessive penalty fees and failing to fully disclose their fees, policies and practices to consumers ["Credit Cards' Hidden Costs," Business, Oct. 12].
Because the GAO was focused on direct consumer fees, the report missed an even larger hidden fee consumers ultimately pay: the interchange fees charged on virtually every purchase. Hidden from consumers because credit card contracts effectively prohibit their disclosure, these fees were over $30 billion in 2005 alone -- more than double the amount card companies collected in late fees.
Many Americans have never heard of interchange. Even though interchange averages close to 2 percent of every credit or debit card transaction, Visa and MasterCard rules effectively prohibit merchants from telling consumers how much these fees cost them. Interchange acts as a hidden sales tax on U.S. commerce, raising merchant costs and, ultimately, the price of goods and services sold to consumers.
Fees that are intentionally hidden from consumers create a system in which people lack the information they need to make sound decisions about their electronic payment choices. This does not reflect a market in which normal, competitive forces are working. It's time for that to change. If credit card companies insist on gouging consumers, at least let's ask them to be honest about it.
TIM HAMMONDS
President and Chief Executive
Food Marketing Institute
Washington
[Source: Letter to the Editor, The Washington Post]
Friday, October 20, 2006
"National Restaurant Association Comments on Announcement that Visa® Will Publish Interchange Fee Schedule on Web Site" (NRA)
"While we are pleased that Visa now appears willing to post its fee schedule, we are still asking for full disclosure of all the rules by which merchants must abide, and will be demanding this in the litigation against Visa and MasterCard®," said Todd Mann, senior vice president of Business Development at the National Restaurant Association.
"While Visa states that the rules are available, they are only available to those merchants who have already agreed to accept the credit card, and only after that merchant signs a non-disclosure agreement. Should a merchant be considering whether or not to accept Visa, they should be able to see all the terms of the agreement before signing the contract," said Mann.
The Merchants Payments Coalition is comprised of about 20 trade associations representing well over half of the interchange transactions in the U.S. The group represents retailers, restaurants, supermarkets, drug stores, convenience stores, gas stations, on-line merchants and other businesses that accept debit and credit cards.
The National Restaurant Association, founded in 1919, is the leading business association for the restaurant industry, which is comprised of 925,000 restaurant and foodservice outlets and a work force of 12.5 million employees - making it the cornerstone of the economy, career opportunities and community involvement. Along with the National Restaurant Association Educational Foundation, the Association works to represent, educate and promote the rapidly growing industry. For more information, visit our Web site at www.restaurant.org.
[source: National Restaurant Association, via their website press release]
"Rewards Account for 44% of Interchange Cost, Report Concludes" (Digital Transactions)
"The days of merchant-subsidized credit card rewards programs, rapid increases in interchange fees, and confusing fee structures for credit card purchases are numbered, according to new research by Diamond Management & Technology Consultants, Inc. Pressure from Merchants Compels Credit Card Industry to Build New Business Models, According to New Diamond Report Billions in Interchange Fees, Customer Loyalty Programs at Risk as Banks, Card Issuers and Card Associations Face Merchant Backlash and New Competition," [From the Diamond Consultants website].
- The costs of air miles and other perks and rewards account for 44% of bank card interchange
- Card issuers’ cost of funds and profit margins take 35%
- Network branding efforts account for 3%
- 13% of the acquirer-paid fee goes toward various transaction-processing costs from which merchants derive a direct benefit
- Interchange fees were subsidizing increasingly generous cardholder giveaways and other marketing programs
- The report also underscores how much in the dark it says most retailers are regarding details of the fees
- “Merchants really have little idea where their interchange dollars go,” says the report.
- The fee structure itself can be confusing to merchants
[Source: Digital Travensactions, via report from The Diamond Report]
----
According to ASIATravelTips, MasterCard is even offering helicopter trips and 70,000 other prizes in its Macau sweepstakes.
Casualties of Technology (WayTooHigh.com)
Study the changes to your industry against the banks and credit card associations. For us, our two separate industries also transitioned but had vastly divergent outcomes as technology forced changes. We made changes, the other one (in our opinion) is protected by the banking cartel.
Film
As a longtime and well-known leader in the photo imaging industry, 30 Minute Photos Etc. was
forced to adapt. Today, very little business is derived from traditional film processing; it is mostly digital. Our customer-base is nationwide today. However, we would have no customers if we were still imposing a film developing charge for each online, in-store kiosk and other digital orders. If you have us make Kodak-quality photographic prints from your digital camera, you would be concerned if there was an added fee for film processing. Right?Electronic Charge Card Payment Transactions
Think of the 30-billion dollar annual merchant interchange fee boondoggle. It was organized decades ago to cover the cost to process and clear carbon-copy credit card receipts. Today it is more of an untouchable, ghostly bank annuity - even as technology and efficiencies have altered its underpinnings.
Just like with film and many other products and services, the business has changed. However, Visa® and MasterCard's® member banks continue to maintain artificially high interchange fees because we allege it is set by illegal price-fixing and not subject to regular competitive forces. The conspiracy by the banks and their market power forgets that merchants remember the old-fashioned cred
it card imprinters and what interchange fees were designed to cover. The reward games and other schemes developed by Visa and MasterCard come at an added cost to merchants, cardholders and all consumers who eventually fund the banks interchange annuity.
Note: There are no interchange fees for writing and clearing checks. There are even no interchange fees in Canada for PIN debit card transactions. The merchant interchange fees in third-world countries are even lower than rates charged in the States.
[Source: WayTooHigh.com]
Thursday, October 19, 2006
Are Airlines Double Carded? (WayTooHigh.com)
This is a double tax on the airlines.
A recent CNBC news profile on American Airlines® identified some interesting facts about credit card frequent flyer "rewards" and parnership programs:
- American Airlines has 50 million AAdvantage program loyalty members
- Of the more than one-thousand AAdvantage program partners, credit cards are the largest partners
- 1/2 of all frequent flyer miles are earned from non-flying sources
- There are nearly ten-trillion unused miles
- Demand for redemption is very high and it is not easy to cash in
- New gimmick: AAnytime mileage costs flyers two-times the regular points to redeem
- Most profitable segment: airlines selling miles to banks; they get the funds upfront; generates $3-billion dollar annually for the airlines
- 1/3 of all miles are not redeemed
- Actual variable cost to the airlines to redeem 25,000 miles, when not displacing a revenue generating seat is just $10.00
What this means is that the incentive to have caredholders pay for products with credit cards is actually a sizable expense to businesses and consumers. It appears that Visa® and MasterCard's® member banks are the real benefactors. The perception is that there is a rich value to cardholders, but do the math to understand that businesses accepting credit cards are also being taking on a ride ... and a costly one at that.
Why frequent-flyer plans keep you grounded
[Source WayTooHigh.com, via CNBC: "Inside American Airlines"]
"Visa® Publishes Interchange Fees For Credit Cards" (ConsumerAffiars.com)
Visa has taken the unusual step of publishing a list of "interchange fees" it charges merchants to process their credit and debit cards when customers make transactions with plastic. The fees are often called a "hidden tax on consumers," as they can drive up the price of goods and services without consumers' knowledge.
It's these interchange fees that have led a coalition of merchants and retailers to sue Visa, MasterCard®, and their partner banks, over what the merchants call collusive price-fixing. The interchange fee list, available as a PDF report, is a bewildering array of "performance thresholds" and "reimbursement fees" that seems to require a degree in calculus to understand.
The basic gist is that different cards and different purchases end up costing merchants different fees to process, ranging from 1 to 2 percent of the transaction plus change.
When you factor in the billions of credit and debit transactions that go on in the world daily, 1 percent of a purchase can add up to millions in revenue for banks and card companies. It can also wipe out the retailer's profit from a transaction.
In order to make a profit, merchants will often raise prices on their goods and services, even for those who pay exclusively with cash.
The Merchant Payments Coalition, the group representing retail and restaurant chains, hailed the move but said that it wasn't enough to simply reveal the fees, and that more transparency was needed in the business.
"The report shows a bewildering array of rates for different cards, merchants and types of transactions, which emphasizes the opacity of interchange," said MPC chairman Mallory Duncan. Duncan also noted the recent Government Accountability Office (GAO) report on the poor disclosure of credit card fees to consumers, saying it was "no surprise" that merchant fees would be similarly hard to understand.
Although Visa had originally claimed it would not publish its interchange fee rates, the world's largest credit card company reversed course after chief rival MasterCard agreed to do so in an attempt to appease the merchants suing the company.
Visa recently announced its own initial public stock offering, after eyeing the success of MasterCard's debut on the market. The MasterCard IPO is chiefly designed to build a "war chest" of funds to pay for litigation and settlements in the merchant lawsuits, thereby shifting the risk to investors rather than the member banks that formerly owned MasterCard.
Mitch Goldstone, one of the lead plaintiffs in the class-action merchant lawsuits, said on his blog that Visa and MasterCard should post the exact interchange fee of each transaction on the customer's receipt.
"Without this honest and straightforward posting, this hidden tax will continue to feed Visa and MasterCards' member banks with thirty billion dollars each year," Goldstone said.
[Source: ConsumerAffairs.com]
B of A Surge in Card Fees; Profits Rise 41% in Qtr (via Reuters)
- Debit card income increased 24 percent from the same quarter last year to $502 million and purchase volume grew 19 percent to a record $42.86 billion. Bank of America customers made more than 1 billion transactions with their debit cards during the quarter. Bank of America’s market share of debit card transactions is 16 percent, twice that of the nearest competitor.
- Card Services had revenue of $5.33 billion, an increase of 137 percent compared to the third quarter of 2005. Net income more than tripled to $1.48 billion. On a pro forma basis, Card Services recorded an increase in revenue of 7 percent compared to the third quarter of 2005, while net income increased 47 percent.
- Bank of America Corp. (NYSE:BAC - news), the No. 2 U.S. bank, on Thursday said third-quarter profit rose 41 percent, helped by consumer lending growth and a surge in credit card fees. [via Reuters]
[Source: via Edgar]
Wednesday, October 18, 2006
News Update - Goldstone to Address Major Intl Conference
As the first lead plaintiff in the merchant antitrust litigation, Goldstone is also co-founder of 30 Minute Photos Etc. and co-edits WayTooHigh.com - The Credit Card Interchange Report. He has recently addressed other conferences in Orlando, Las Vegas and Minneapolis.
The Wild Ride Continues: An Interchangeable Menu of Payment Card Schemes (Commentary: WayTooHigh.com)
PUBLISHING FEES WHERE IT WILL BE NOTICED AND UNDERSTOOD
Although Visa® just posted their interchange fee schedule on its website, it is confusing and draws more attention to their scores of separate fees. Instead, Visa and MasterCard® should be completely transparent and post the exact interchange fee on each customer's charge card receipt. Once consumers and retailers understand the real extent of these charges, the volume of outrage will be amplified. Without this honest and straightforward posting, this hidden tax will continue to feed Visa and MasterCards' member banks with thirty billion dollars each year.
DEBIT CARD-GAMES
According a Consumer Reports (Nov. 2006) article, PIN-based transactions are "15 times more secure than signature-based transactions, says Tony Hayes, a vice president at Dove Consulting, a Boston financial-services consulting group."
However, Visa and MasterCard really want consumers to use these safer cards as signature cards because they make more money. There are many new schemes employed by Visa and MasterCard to embolden debit card users to pressure merchants to process the transactions at the much higher percent-of-sale rather than flat-rate fee. The latest gimmick was announced today and is more of a spoof on how to fiscally prepare families for the costs of higher education.
Consumer Reports’ (Nov, 2006) profile provided additional insights: "To encourage you to use their cards, some banks offer reward programs that let you collect points, usually for choosing debit transactions that are completed with your signature rather than a PIN. Make $9,000 in signature debits with your Citibank card, for example, and you can cash in your 4,500 points for a Dirt Devil hand vac, a $50 value. But these rewards help banks boost fees to their merchant customers. Banks charge retailers significantly more to process signature debits than they do PIN-based debits--77 cents vs. 25 cents on a $100 sale. Visa says merchants get higher traffic and revenue from its branded signature debits. Maximize it. Don’t choose your bank or debit card based on rewards. Debit-card benefits equal only about a 0.5 percent rebate on each dollar spent. It could take years to rack up points for a reward. Moreover, retailers are complaining about being forced to pay more, and Congress is investigating. These programs might not be around long enough for you to collect."
DON’T HOLD YOUR BREATH FOR FREE TUITION
Earlier today, MasterCard Worldwide announced a new college savings reward program for Debit MasterCard. In their words: "... launch of an innovative debit card rewards program that will provide cardholders a new way to save for the rising costs of higher education." We wonder what the costs are to merchants and cardholders for this Upromise MasterCard Debit Card Rewards Program "rewards points?" Is it only valid towards signature transactions? With other programs, PIN cardholders are seduced but earn nothing unless they insist that merchants complete the transactions at the much higher signature rates. From what we can guess, a family who enrolls in this Debit MasterCard program when their children are still infants might at best "buy" them a seat at a junior college and then just to audit one class.
These games and lavish incentives to spend more must end.
Rhetorically, why don’t banks offer these perks to PIN transactions?
These obsolete interchange fees must end too.
We would like to see PIN-based debit cardholders involve retailers and request they complete each electronic payment transaction as PIN, rather than signature rates.
PIN CAMPAIGN: What would happen if on the day after Thanksgiving - "Black Friday," the busiest shopping day of the year - cardholders selected to use debit cards as debit cards?
Every day our customers prod us to run their debit cards as credit cards so they earn points, rewards and other gimmicks. If they only knew how much it was costing them!
HISTORICAL PROSPECTIVE
More than 16-years ago, 30 Minute Photos Etc. was founded in Orange county, Calif. when film was king and digital cameras were a futuristic invention. Also, back then, we used credit card imprinters to swipe traditional payment cards over a thick stack of carbon copy receipts. Along with million of other merchants, after processing and clearing those receipts we were charged interchange fees that were cost-based; there were just a handful of various interchange categories.Despite huge technological and infrastructure advancement in the photo and banking industries, only one has made adjustments and lowered its fees. In our opinion, the other is operated by a highly sophisticated cartel that illegally controls and manipulates rates.Sixteen months ago, our company was the first to file an anticompetitive complaint against the two leading credit card associations. Nearly 50 suits have followed ours. Since then, the card associations and member banks have throttled backwards and done some impressive backpedaling. When we called for them to resciend interchange fees at service stations, they slowly responded with heavy-handed window dressing placing a $50 cap on interchange fees at the pumps; most motorists pay less than that anyway.
Recently, Visa announced a restructuring. But, if they think that passing along the antitrust liabilities into public hands will solve its problems, they might consider going to a restaurant. Talk to restaurant owners. Understand how passionate and decisive are their arguments which are shared with merchants across the country and abroad.With Visa and MasterCard's member banks aggressively promoting debit cards, merchants are in an added bind. When a diner at a restaurant pays with a debit card, funds are quickly withdrawn from their account, yet the establishment is forced to process the cards as credit cards and pay the much higher interchange fees. Think of your experience. Servers at most restaurants do not have portable electronic PIN terminals so PIN-based debit cards are transacted at the much higher signature rates.
[Commentary: WayTooHigh.com - The Credit Card Interchange Report]
"Merchants Respond to Visa's Release of Default Interchange Rates" (Merchants Payments Coalition)
"This announcement by Visa begins to shed a much-needed spotlight on the excessive interchange rates merchants and consumers are forced to pay on virtually every credit or debit card transaction. It is evident that Visa has felt the pressure of congressional scrutiny and merchant outrageover these anti-competitive practices, since as recently as September they maintained that these fees were already available."
"The release of these interchange rates brings to light the need forfurther transparency. The report shows a bewildering array of rates for different cards, merchants and types of transactions, which emphasizes the opacity of interchange. Without the operating rules that govern how these fees are applied, this announcement falls far short of the disclosure that is required and that Visa promised in testimony before Congress this summer. Given the recent GAO report on Visa and MasterCard's failure to clearly disclose fees and terms to consumers, their lack of transparency in dealing with merchants should come as no surprise."
"Our position is clear. The collective setting of interchange fees by Visa and MasterCard violates the antitrust laws and costs merchants and consumers $30 billion a year. Visa and MasterCard need to fulfill the promises they made in testimony to the Senate Judiciary Committee to provide their full operating rules. Only when the full picture of the interchange puzzle is complete can Congress decide what further action maybe required."
Duncan also noted that Visa's announcement inaccurately stated that merchants "do not pay interchange" but pay a merchant discount fee instead. In fact, interchange is a non-negotiable fee paid as part of the merchant discount fee, accounting for approximately 80 percent of the total merchant discount fee.
The Merchants Payments Coalition is a group of about 20 trade associations representing retailers, restaurants, supermarkets, drugstores, convenience stores, gas stations, on-line merchants and other businesses that accept debit and credit cards. MPC is fighting for a more competitive and transparent card system that works better for consumers and merchants alike. The coalition's member associations collectively represent about 2.7 million stores with approximately 50 million employees.
[Source: Merchants Payments Coalition]
Tuesday, October 17, 2006
"Visa, Following MasterCard, to Disclose More Fees" (Reuters)
[Source: Reuters]
"Fewer Rewards for Frequent Triers" (The Sydney Morning Herald)
[Source: The Sydney Morning Herald]
Monday, October 16, 2006
"NACS Chairman Addresses Hot Issues" (NACS)
LAS VEGAS -- “It will be a few weeks before we will know the makeup of the next Congress, good, bad or ugly. But whichever, I can tell you our agenda won’t change,” said NACS incoming Chairman of the Board Sam Turner during his Closing General Sessions remarks at the NACS Show 2006.
"NACS will continue to protect and defend our industry. No matter which issues come up we’ll stay the course and fight for what’s right,” he told attendees.
The biggest and toughest battle, one that Turner compared to “walking up to King Kong and pulling a hair out of his chest,” is over credit card interchange fees.
“Last year our industry paid almost as much in credit card fees as we saw in profits. That’s absurd!” stressed Turner.
But there is promise, noted Turner. Because of NACS, Capitol Hill is paying very close attention to the issue of credit card fees. “Through our efforts, both the House and Senate understand just how outrageous these fees are and that the system is broken,” Turner said. “The battle against the credit card companies will be difficult and NACS will push even further and harder in the next Congress.” ,,,
------------------------
Credit Card Fees Got You Down? NACS Can Help!Card fees are definitely top of mind. [Read] what Convenience Store Decisions magazine has to say.
------------------------
[Source: NACS]
"NACS Chairman Addresses Hot Issues" (NACS)
LAS VEGAS -- “It will be a few weeks before we will know the makeup of the next Congress, good, bad or ugly. But whichever, I can tell you our agenda won’t change,” said NACS incoming Chairman of the Board Sam Turner during his Closing General Sessions remarks at the NACS Show 2006.
"NACS will continue to protect and defend our industry. No matter which issues come up we’ll stay the course and fight for what’s right,” he told attendees.
The biggest and toughest battle, one that Turner compared to “walking up to King Kong and pulling a hair out of his chest,” is over credit card interchange fees.
“Last year our industry paid almost as much in credit card fees as we saw in profits. That’s absurd!” stressed Turner.
But there is promise, noted Turner. Because of NACS, Capitol Hill is paying very close attention to the issue of credit card fees. “Through our efforts, both the House and Senate understand just how outrageous these fees are and that the system is broken,” Turner said. “The battle against the credit card companies will be difficult and NACS will push even further and harder in the next Congress.” ,,,
[Source: NACS]
Sunday, October 15, 2006
"Visa's Initial Offering Expected to Fetch $5-Billion" (The Globe and Mail)
[Source: The Globe and Mail]
Thursday, October 12, 2006
But, the Alleged Crimes Have Already Been Committed (WayTooHigh.com)
What they are scheming reminds us of two mischievous adolescents. You know the scenario; the older, much bigger brother uses the younger sibling to test the waters. If he doesn't get caught, then the older teen pounces. The same banks which controlled MasterCard® and Visa did just that several months ago. They tested the waters with MasterCard's IPO and now they are plotting for the much bigger brother to follow.
Just as with MasterCard, the plans for a new entity called Visa, Inc. will not insulate the nearly identical group of member banks. Instead, it draws more convincing proof that the two card associations got caught with their hands in the cookie jar and are rushing to slam the lid on without getting caught again. We are talking billions and billions of dollars and years of transgressions, yet the bank-controlled cartel thinks that the legal damages from our charges of antitrust violations and illegal price-fixing will be softened and diverted.
The pages of dire Risk Factors that will be published within Visa, Inc's offering documents will explain all this in detail.
[commentary: WayTooHigh.com]
"Charge it to Investors" (Marketplace)
Excerpt...
MasterCard recently went public, now Visa says it's planning to do the same. Ashley Milne-Tyte looks at why the biggest names in credit cards are going public now.
Right now the credit card giant Visa is basically a private membership club. It's controlled by a network of banks. But yesterday, Visa said it's gonna reorganize and become a publicly-traded company. MasterCard went public in May. So what's up with this? Ashley Milne-Tyte reports.
It's about the money. Visa is facing a lawsuit from merchants claiming the company charges them artificially high fees each time a customer uses a Visa. Going public means the banks who now own Visa are protected from legal claims. And there'll be plenty more of those says Robert Manning, author of Credit Card Nation.
[Source: Marketplace]
Visa's® Planned Restructuring Sounds Like Musical Chairs (commentary: WayTooHigh.com)
As the payment industry quickly runs out of chairs to hide under, the music is getting louder. The international battle lead by all-sized retailers over antitrust violations are forcing fewer places for the banks to hide. Today's announcement by Visa, which controls about 65% of total card sales volume, will create a giant publicly-held global corporation that raises new questions.
Their goal is probably to reduce its member banks' legal risks by shoving the antitrust liability into public hands. Just review the previous bank-controlled MasterCard® IPO and it's Risk Factors to understand what is at stake.
The encouraging news from Visa's press release is that the bank-owned credit card association expects that the new structure and capital inflow will strengthen their product development and innovations. For any other industry this means lower prices and more efficiencies. But, based on their record of unbridled price increases, it will be interesting to watch what happens to merchant interchange fees. Years ago, these were the cost-based charges when retailers used credit card imprinters and thick stacks of carbon-copy receipts to manually transact business. Even as technology has moved forward at lightening-fast speed, interchange fees have also risen too.
Part of the plan is for the credit card association to install an independent board of directors. Moving forward, this helps remedy the antitrust charges that the bank-controlled board conspired to set merchant fees at artificially high levels. Currently, interchange fees are not subject to regular competitive forces; it should be set by competition, not illegal price fixing by agreement.
According to MarketWatch, UBS advised its clients that "We believe Visa is unlikely to consider aggressively cutting rates and thereby eroding revenues as a for-profit entity ... [h]ence, we believe this move is supportive of pricing...."
In our opinion, when a perpetrator of a crime prepares for court, they often clean up their appearance. Polishing up, getting a nice suit and doing the right thing is customary. But, make no mistake, in this case it is nothing more than musical chairs and window dressing. Visa’s restructuring, along with MasterCard and their thousands of member banks are still being charged with breaking the law spanning many, many years; illegal price-fixing is a crime.
The Visa announcement today only signals their intent to proceed with a public offering within the next 12-18 months. Even if they are successful, the announcement itself does not change anything.
In discussing the reasons for the IPO, both Visa and MasterCard seem to think that hiding behind public ownership will help them avoid antitrust liabilities. To us, this is just another admission that their years of collusive price-fixing have violated antitrust laws and I expect that a jury will agree with them!
While the goal of Visa’s IPO might be to insulate it and their member banks from antitrust liabilities, if Visa’s restructuring agreements are prepared like MasterCard’s, then it too will violate the antitrust laws.
[Source: Commentary, WayTooHigh.com]
Wednesday, October 11, 2006
"IPO Plan Reflects Desire to Head Off Critics" (Financial Times)
[Source: Financial Times]
Visa® News Recap
"Visa charges ahead with IPOCredit card brand to unify regional operations ahead of IPO" (MarketWatch) [Note: This article includes commentary by lead plaintiff, Mitch Goldstone]
"Visa execs tout IPO as best way to move forward" (MarketWatch)
"Visa rings up plans for IPO" (Times UK)
"Visa Announces Global Restructuring" (Visa online press release)
"Market Forces, Including Interchange Cases, Spur Visa to Plan for IPO" (Digital Transactions)
Visa Restructuring (AP)
Tuesday, October 10, 2006
"The Interchange Fee Debate: Issues and Economics" (From June, 2006 - Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis)
Monday, October 09, 2006
Tuesday, October 03, 2006
Out of Touch (WayTooHigh.com)
[commentary: WayToohigh.com]
Monday, October 02, 2006
"Unraveling the Card-Processing Conundrum" (Business New Jersey, subscription required)
[source: Business New Jersey, subscription required]
Saturday, September 30, 2006
Wednesday, September 27, 2006
MasterCard Rate Increase?! (WayTooHigh.com)
MasterCard® is actually preparing another assault on merchants and consumers. According to the NACS, they will again raise merchant interchange rates in mid-October.
It seems that little has changed.
Their plan is to increase World card rates on Oct 14th and the increase is widespread. We don't see any rates declining, but rising. Supermarkets are especially penalized. The new rates are increasing by about 4 percent at a time that our antitrust litigation should be causing pause.
The rate increases will apply to many cards, including: World Elite Standard, World Elite Key-Entered, World Elite Convenience, World Elite Supermarket, World Elite Warehouse, World Elite Public Sector, World Elite Restaurant.
[source: via NACS, WayTooHigh.com]
"Black Friday" (WayTooHigh.com)
We are wondering.
What would happen if on the day after Thanksgiving, on what is known as "Black Friday" - the busiest shopping day - when the credit card cartel is again poised to reap billions, if consumers demanded merchants process their debit cards as .... debit cards, rather than credit cards.
In drawing attention to the interchange fees, this campaign would canvas the nation with attention and raise more questions about the unbridled profiteering by Visa® and MasterCard®. Shoppers would signal they support their favorite stores. Rather than paying the banks a percent of every sale, retailers would then turn over a much smaller flat fee. The card association's are fighting back with contest gimmicks and promotions to force consumers to have stores swipe the cards at the much more costly credit card rates.
During the next few weeks we will explore how to promote and implement this plan.
[Commentary: WayTooHigh.com]
Saturday, September 23, 2006
Commentary on Technology, Fighting Mad Merchants and Real Blogs (WayTooHigh.com)
A newly invented silicon chip uses lasers, rather than wires to exponentially speed up information at a fraction of the cost. So, why is the credit card cartel initiating promotional gimmicks like caps on fill-up fees when motorists pay over $50 rather than lowering all rates due to advances in technology?
Is it greed, arrogance, or, just because they can?
Moore's Law of cost savings and technology efficiencies is one more reason why the $30 billion dollar annual interchange windfall forced upon consumers and merchants is infuriating many.
MERCHANTS ARE FIGHTING MAD
During an address to a Las Vegas photo industry conference this week, I heard from many retailers. Their concerns on interchange were interchangeable; each had stories about the fees and were all fighting mad. In all cases, their issues paralleled other retailers I hear from. They are mad as hell and not going to take it any more. One fellow attendee from Boston even mentioned the 1970s film Network and congratulated my partner and I as the very first lead plaintiffs for not just getting passionate, but taking action. I explained how the April, 2005 Wall Street Journal column (front page Marketplace) was partly the catalyst for leading us to become the personalities behind and foundation for this global battle.
His words and personal experience have become a new center piece in our personal battle with Visa®, MasterCard® and their member banks. No other person has ever expressed their appreciation for our role in filing the very first antitrust suit quit like him. He explained that after the horrors of September 11th, hearing stories about people standing up to injustice meant the world to him. His world profoundly changed on that day; his wife was on American Airlines' flight 11 and one of those lost on September 11th.
REAL BLOGS
We learned that the new hit NBC program 'Studio 60' had some technology marketing that was meant to appear as if fans of the show were hosting genuine blogs. Saturday's Los Angeles Times reported that the blog backfired because it was actually written by the network and underhandly was actually a "faux-blog." This is one more way corporate giants are designing unlevel playing fields, although the NBC faux blog was turned off hours ago and perhaps for good..
More about this example of a phony corporate blog from a Defamer.com blog posting:
While we found Defamer doppleganger Defaker, NBC's attempt to virally promote Studio 60 through a blog that seems to report gossip about the show's fictional universe in the form of interminably long episode summaries, an uncomfortably accurate commentary on our own half-assed efforts in the medium, we did unexpectedly discover something on the site to occupy our time: the open comments section of their inaugural post, a weird place where messages indulging the blog's premise (seemingly both from NBC staffers and people willing to play along with the joke), reviews of the show's pilot episode, opinions on the site's execution of its viral vision (verdict: try harder if you're going to bother), and general ragging on Amanda Peet's acting ability uncomfortably coexist. Here's a round-up of our favorite examples from the past couple of days:
Real people, real blogs and honest narratives will always beat out giant conglomerates' attempts to sway opinion. Just look at the credit card cartels efforts and compare it to WayTooHigh.com - The Credit Card Interchange Report. In their cases advocacy groups which enjoyed the financial support of Visa®, for instance, issued press releases and promoted the bank-owned views. Commentaries in newspapers also advocating their point of view must be measured by the people behind the curtain.[commentary: WayTooHigh.com]
Monday, September 18, 2006
Background News Items on 30 Minute Photos Etc. (Kiosk Market Place)
by James Bickers, editor • 18 Sep 2006 - Kiosk Market Place
When Fred Schwartz returned from a recent 16-day trip to Italy, the retired phone-company worker had a lot of pictures to print. As usual, he took his memory cards to 30 Minute Photos Etc.in his hometown of Irvine, Calif. But this time was different: Rather than hand the cards across the counter, Fred sat down at a photo kiosk and took matters into his own hands. He got hands-on assistance from storeowner Mitch Goldstone, plus some above-and-beyond treatment.
"Halfway through, he brings me cold bottled water and a candy bar," he said. "I’ve never been exposed to anyone helping out the customer that much, the extra step. I’m just not used to that kind of personalized service."
30 Minute Photos is indicative of an emerging trend where photo retailers use self-service in tandem with extraordinary customer service to create an atmosphere where people want to linger. Call it the "Starbucks effect."
"I’m using his services more and more," Schwartz said. "It’s just so comfortable in his store."
Catering to ‘Jennifer’
The proliferation of digital cameras has been good news and bad news for photo retailers — more people are taking more pictures, but they’re also printing them at home in large number. The Photo Marketing Association International reports that 61 percent of the digital photos printed in 2004 were done on home printers, versus 31 percent at retail. Retailers did better in 2005, but the majority of prints were still made at home.
"For the specialty photo retailer to survive, they have to clearly identify their target market and design an experience around that market," said Chad Munce, PMA’s group executive for digital-imaging markets. "If you consider the demographic of the memory-keepers in the household that are buying photographic products and services, you will see that the Generation X mom — PMA calls her ‘Jennifer’ — is the primary target for photo kiosk services."
Patrons use the DigiPrint Lounge at Dan's Camera City, Allentown, Pa.At Dan’s Camera City in Allentown, Pa., the experience is clearly aimed at Jennifer. The store’s 450-square-foot "DigiPrint Lounge" features 15 kiosk stations, each featuring a custom-designed stool, purse hooks and a La-Z-Boy chair for friends and family. A children’s entertainment area is nearby, and staffers are on hand with free coffee and other drinks. The lighting in the entire area is reduced, cutting down on glare on the Lucidiom kiosks.
"Customers — especially women — seek out the lounge," said Michael Woodland, chief executive of Dan’s. "It is relaxed, provides all they support they could wish for in terms of entertaining the kids, having a knowledgeable person at the ready, and easy-to-use systems."
Mitch Goldstone took a similar approach to 30 Minute Photos in June, when he remodeled the store to give it more of a boutique feel. "We redesigned the entire store — it was getting old-looking," he said. "There was a lot of clutter, and there wasn’t any of the type of merchandising and marketing that takes place in, say, a Starbucks. We wanted to create a unique destination experience, designed to make people stay and play."
At 30 Minute Photos in Irvine, Calif., a staffer teaches a customer to use the Lucidiom "Luci" kiosk.For 30 Minute Photos, that experience includes full-spectrum lighting, a high-end air filtration system, and a refrigerator full of Voss water and Ghirardelli chocolate — complimentary for customers.
"You go into the Ritz Carlton, for example, and they’ve always got fruit available at the front desk for their customers," he said. "That’s got a special magic to it, and we wanted that for our store."
The magic continues when customers leave, too — Goldstone said he hands out single-serving containers of Haagen-Dazs to departing shoppers. Goldstone said he couldn’t give specific revenue figures, but did say sales had risen 60 percent since June, when the store makeover took place.
"That’s an enormous number, especially when you consider that the traditional photo industry is down about 20 percent," he said. "We feel it’s extraordinary."
Paying more for the experience
"Why would anyone pay a dollar for a bookmark?" Steven Spielberg once asked. "Why not use a dollar as a bookmark?"
Spielberg’s frugal viewpoint underscores an aspect of human nature that is pivotal for retailers: the emotion of buying. In any given city, you can find a cup of coffee for a dollar or less. You also can find a $4 cup of coffee in that same town, very likely on the same block.
What justifies the difference? Taste and quality are part of it, but not all. Customers pay more for a positive buying experience, and interestingly, the phenomenon is not diminished with awareness — even if you know you’re paying way too much for coffee, you’ll occasionally do it anyway, because you enjoy it.
Dr. Michael Kasavana, professor of hospitality business at Michigan State University, said this phenomenon is well documented, and can be put to good use by the photo retail industry. "There is much research to indicate that a comfortable environment encourages more effective purchase decisions, and likely more spending," he said. "Additionally, a personal loyalty tends to be attached to the comfort station and hence a higher propensity for repeat business."
In the case of Dan’s Camera City, higher quality prints coupled with the "lounge experience" have justified higher prices — which customers are happily paying. "We are 29 cents for a 4-by-6," Woodland said. "That’s not a lot compared to other specialty stores, but certainly more than the local 19-cent big-box stores or the 9-cent online companies. In our case it is quality and experience. We do produce prints which are noticeably superior to these other sources, so there is a double incentive for them to choose us — allowing us to appeal to both the left and right side of their brain."
At 30 Minute Photos, prices used to hang on the walls. After the June makeover, they are nowhere to be found on the store signage. "Price isn’t an important component any longer," Goldstone said. "People are so dazzled with the service and quality that they don’t question the pricing."
[source: Kiosk Market Place]
Sunday, September 17, 2006
Thursday, September 14, 2006
70% of MasterCard's Board Now Independent (via AP)
[Source: via AP]
Tuesday, September 12, 2006
Is Visa® Taking Clarity and Replacing it with Hubris? (WayTooHigh.com)

Have you seen Visa U.S.A. Inc’s® print ad campaign and "Life Takes Visa®" slogan? (See sample: WSJ, Sept 12, p. B7).
The entire page in today's Wall Street Journal, for instance, contains tiny print to illustrate the complexity of traditional financial statements. Then the particulars: the copy explains that "Visa Business tracks your finances on one simple statement. So you can get your business’ financial story without reading between the lines. ... Your business is your life. Life takes Visa."
More factually, in our opinion, is that Visa® takes clarity and throws it out the window. On one hand, the world’s largest payment processing association promotes keeping it simple - then the fine print. For cardholders, the idea is to track finances with one simple statement, but for merchants, get out your detective’s hat and magnifying glass.
The typical merchant processing agreements are one-page, easy to follow forms. That is with the exception of the fine print. I had to zoom in so closely to the First Data Management Services® contract to find the hidden message, which was anything but simple. Look for yourself, request any merchant services company's processing agreement. What you will typically find is one sentence within the application and agreement that speaks volumes about how this game works.
Ex: "The client acknowledges having received and read a copy of the Interchange Schedule, Program Guide / Confirmation Page and Merchant Processing Application."
For merchants who sign on to accept electronic payments, for instance, there is hushed clarity followed by a multi, multi-paged, legal-ease appendix of non-simple-to-understand compliance; it is anything but fluent in simplicity.
Life might take Visa®, but for merchants accepting the cards, it could take seemingly a lifetime of reading and research to understand about interchange fees and how the leading payment processing association operates. Like the Visa® print ads, the contractual forms also have tiny print too which seems designed more to distract from this nearly 30 billion dollars in annual hidden taxes on retailers and consumers.
[Commentary: WayTooHigh.com]
